The Dispossession of Josephine Hatch
A Snohomish widow, unable to speak English, sues a powerful land conglomerate for swindling her out of a multi-million dollar stake in the founding of Everett.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
Mrs. Josephine Hatch, the widow of Ezra Hatch, has brought a suit in the United States court against E. C. Ferguson, Henry Hewitt, Jr., and the Everett Land Company, involving the title to 324 acres of land within the townsite of Everett, valued at nearly one and three-quarter million dollars. Mrs. Hatch, a full-blooded Indian who cannot read, write, or speak English, claims she was defrauded of her property. Her late husband, Ezra Hatch, purchased the land from the United States in 1874 and lived there until his death in 1890. The land lies on a valuable peninsula between the Snohomish River and Port Gardner Bay. According to the complaint, E. C. Ferguson, acting as executor of the estate and guardian to her children, exploited her inability to speak English. Ferguson spoke to her in Chinook jargon and gained her trust. He eventually misrepresented a document as a request for settlement, which was in fact a power of attorney allowing him to sell her property. Following this, Henry Hewitt, Jr., president of the Everett Land Company, orchestrated a series of deeds and fraudulent court proceedings that stripped Mrs. Hatch and her children of their holdings for a fraction of their worth. Ferguson allegedly moved her to a small house on a nearly worthless lot, where she lived until discovering the depth of the fraud. Mrs. Hatch is now seeking to have these deeds cancelled and to be declared the rightful owner of the land.
“Mrs. Hatch is a full-blooded Indian, unable to write or even speak English, and claims that suit is made necessary through her having been defrauded of the property by reason of her ignorance.”
The story of the Everett Land Company's aggressive consolidation of territory mirrors the modern displacement of long-term residents and marginalized populations during Seattle's rapid development cycles. The use of language barriers and legal complexity as tools for dispossession remains a hauntingly familiar tactic in real estate history.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.