The Collapse of a Workingman's Dream
A bold attempt at worker-owned enterprise in Tacoma ends in financial failure and legal recriminations.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
The Washington Trading and Manufacturing Company was organized in Tacoma in the spring of 1887, during the agitation among the workingmen for the principle of cooperative enterprise. It was incorporated with a capital of one million dollars. The incorporators were active leaders of the workingmen, such as J. H. Graham and Thomas Maloney. The objects of the company embraced a wide range of industrial enterprises, but it eventually confined its operations to the establishment of cooperative stores for the workingmen. Mr. Brook Johnson, in the winter of 1887, canvassed Pierce County for subscriptions and raised $4,000, which was the total cash capital of the concern. With this they started two stores; one in New Tacoma and the other in Old Tacoma. Disagreements soon broke out among the patrons and subscribers—one principal cause of complaint being the systematic lowering of the standard of wages among the employees of the stores in order to enable the concern to 'cut under' the trade generally in prices. This displeased alike the workingmen and the other storekeepers of the two towns. The matter entered largely into the canvass for municipal offices last spring, and had much to do with the crushing defeat of the Coalition Labor ticket. This defeat tended to make the cooperative stores unpopular; the workingmen withdrew their patronage, and many of those, it is said, refused to pay their bills, and the enterprise began to lose money. And now, McCracken & Co., of San Francisco, having procured an attachment against the stores, these have been closed up. The affidavit for the attachment charges the concern with having incurred the debts fraudulently.
“The objects of the company embraced a wide range of industrial enterprises, but it eventually confined its operations to the establishment of cooperative stores for the workingmen.”
Tacoma's 1887 labor experiment echoes modern struggles with gig-economy platforms and worker-led cooperatives. Much like the 1887 effort, the tension between maintaining low consumer prices and ensuring fair living wages for employees remains a defining challenge for cooperative business models today.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.