The Seattle Murder Mystery That Haunted the Front Pages
A desperate man in police custody, a high-stakes life insurance investigation, and a widow caught in the web of suspicion during a sensational 1892 homicide case.
There is no doubt, though the police strenuously deny it, that Louis Kostrauch, who is under arrest on suspicion of being implicated in the supposed murder of William Radloff, has made a confession, and it is said, has implicated Mrs. Radloff in the crime. At 2 o'clock yesterday, the prisoner was brought from his lonely cell into the chief's office. Mayor Ronald and Prosecuting Attorney Miller arrived, along with a man carrying a press for making notarial seals. By 7 o'clock, the prisoner was led back to his cell. It is common talk around police headquarters that he has admitted killing Radloff to secure $55,000 in life insurance money intended for the victim's wife.
Mrs. Virginia Radloff, accompanied by her sister, Ida Creviston, arrived in the city yesterday and sought the advice of attorney Edward P. Edsen. She was indignant at rumors of intimacy between her and Kostrauch, a man she described as a hired hand kept out of charity whom she had often asked her husband to dismiss. Mrs. Radloff had been visiting Lake Bay to prepare for a journey to Germany, and her husband had been worried about his own safety after consulting a medium who predicted he would not live through the year. The investigation continues, with police focusing on the site of the burned house where Radloff is believed to have lost his life.
“Mrs. Radloff was nearly ill from the shock attending the first announcement of the tragedy to her while at home in Lake Bay. She was very angry at the rumors of intimacy between her and Kostrauch.”
This case highlights the enduring obsession with high-profile insurance-motivated homicides and the role of the 'medium' or 'psychic' in 19th-century domestic anxiety—a reminder that before modern forensics, police relied heavily on coerced confessions and public reputation to build a narrative.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.