The Mill That Never Was: How Chicago Capitalists Tried to Buy Seattle’s Soul
In June 1899, Theo. Ludgate arrived in town promising 800 jobs and a massive milling enterprise. Instead, he sparked a legal battle over land leases and vanished back east, leaving behind only the ghost of an industrial boom.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
ANOTHER BIG PLAN! Which Is Soon to Be Located in Seattle by Theo. Ludgate.
ACTING FOR CHICAGO CAPITALISTS Milling Enterprise at Smiths Cove Which Will Give Employment to Eight Hundred Men.
It is stated that water power driven mill of Vancouver, B.C., is to be established on the west side of the entrance of the harbor would "spoil the view."
The local capitalists build a large mill here, according to news received in the city, Mr. Ludgate is at present in St. Louis, conferring with the Chicago capitalists who are interested in the enterprise.
The news received today states that Mr. Ludgate has decided to take the Great Northern site, as he considered Seattle one of the most promising cities on the coast.
Newspaper readers will remember Mr. Ludgate's former struggle to establish a mill on Deadman's Island at Vancouver, B.C. He had for some time secured a lease of the Island for years. When he arrived in Vancouver, he met with great opposition from the city council and from certain local interests.
For months Mr. Ludgate has been waging a mighty battle for location. Twice he landed large forces of men on the island, but were driven off by the city and police. On the second occasion, the big mill man offered resistance, was thrown to the ground, and finally handcuffed and taken to the city.
The matter is now in the provincial courts, and Mr. Ludgate says it is settled as the City of Vancouver and the province of British Columbia for a large sum for damages and losses sustained.
The mill Mr. Ludgate proposes to erect in Seattle will be a mammoth affair. It will, with the men employed at the various timber camps, give work to 800 employees, and will involve a shingle mill and saw far greater than any establishment of the industry here can easily be.
It is understood that work on the mill will commence immediately on Mr. Ludgate's return to Seattle, which will be some time during the present week, speaking of the opposition he met in Vancouver, Mr. Ludgate said in The Star before joining Seattle: "I am Canadian but I am no longer a believer in Canadian justice. My chief opponents were Englishmen—strange that they should send me to this side." He received with open arms and is glad now that these so-called Canadians sent him to this side.
This story captures the volatile nature of Seattle’s early industrial growth, where outside capital often clashed with local control. Ludgate’s failed attempt to build a massive mill mirrors modern debates over corporate development versus community preservation, highlighting how long-standing the tension between economic promise and local sovereignty has been in the Pacific Northwest.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.