The Custody Battle for Little Anna
An aunt and her ex-convict father fight for control of a young girl in Superior Court.
Anna Boynton, a young girl, is at the center of a contest between her maternal aunt and her father. The custody dispute culminated yesterday in habeas corpus proceedings in the superior court. The conflict began on December 19, when Frank R. Boynton carried off the child from her aunt's custody in Lowell, Massachusetts, and brought her to Seattle. The aunt, Miss Paulint, followed him here the next day. Miss Paulint claims the child was born at her home and was raised by her after the child's mother died in 1871, with the father's consent. She alleges that the father is unfit due to his criminal past—including a five-year sentence for embezzlement—and his habits of drinking, gambling, and licentiousness. The father, who resides at 119 Squire Avenue, appeared in court yesterday with the child. Judge Langley refused to place the child in the custody of a stranger and scheduled the final hearing for this afternoon.
“The aunt reared the child from infancy, provided her with a good home and everything that affection could suggest.”
Custody battles in the 1890s often turned on the moral character of the parents, with courts weighing 'fitness' through the lens of Victorian social expectations. Today, Washington courts prioritize the 'best interests of the child,' but the fundamental tension between biological parental rights and the stability of established caregivers remains a deeply human, and often painful, civic conflict.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.