The Judge and the Tenderloin: A Seattle Courtroom Showdown
A Seattle judge loses his temper and issues contempt orders against local law enforcement and the prosecution during a chaotic hearing involving a robbery in the city’s notorious Tenderloin district.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
A hot kind of squabbling was played in profanity ball this morning by Judge Jacobs. By his Honor's order, Deputy Sheriff Wilson must show in court tomorrow morning why he should not be fined for contempt of court, and Deputy Prosecuting Attorney John H. Hart must also show why he should not be either arrested or suspended for his works. It all happened when Steve Lyle and Allan Chaplin were implicated with a man in robbing a man in the Tenderloin last week of several hundred dollars. Judge Jacobs made the public prosecutor furnish the bond and was released. This forenoon, Deputy Sheriff Wilson, under orders from Judge Jacobs, arrested Lyle. Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Hart forbade Wilson to take Lyle in custody and have him re-arrested, to appear as a witness against Chaplin. Lyle was taken to Judge Cann's court and was placed under $500 bonds to appear as a witness in behalf of the state. Lyle was taken back to the county jail and placed behind the bars. John V. Dore, attorney for Lyle, sought a writ of habeas corpus, and Lyle was quickly after given his liberty. As soon as Judge Jacobs heard of the matter, he at once issued orders for Hart and Wilson to appear before him and answer the charges. Wilson's case is set for 4 o'clock and Hart is to appear at 10 a.m. tomorrow forenoon.
“A hot kind of squabbling was played in profanity ball this morning by Judge Jacobs.”
This 1899 dispute over the 'Tenderloin'—Seattle’s historical red-light district—highlights the long-standing friction between judicial authority and the realities of policing street crime. Like today's ongoing debates regarding the 'revolving door' of the justice system and prosecutorial discretion, the struggle to balance public safety with due process has deep roots in the city's civic culture.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.