The Cloroform Clue in the Felling Murder
A specific bottle shape found at a murder scene leads investigators to a Tacoma drug store, renewing interest in a local killing.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
The Seattle police are in possession of a valuable clue in the Felling murder case. It will be remembered that a bottle of chloroform was found in the cabin by the side of the murdered woman. It had never been opened, the cork having been broken in an evident hurried attempt to pull it. The label had been scratched off with premeditated purpose of destroying a clue; but the bottle was of a peculiar shape and the police have spent a great deal of time looking for a druggist who used this form of bottle. Every druggist in this city was visited without success. When Louis Bohn, of Tacoma, a grandson of the murdered woman, was suspected of having committed the murder, an effort was made to find the peculiar form of bottle in a Tacoma drug store. Bohn was allowed to go, however, upon what appeared to be a very plausible alibi to the effect that he was on Whidby Island on the night of the murder. The Tacoma police, however, have continued to search for the druggist who sold the chloroform. They have found bottles of the exact size, shape, and design as the one found in the Fetting cabin in E. A. Tripp's drug store there and have so notified Chief Jackson. Tripp refuses to give any information, but the fact that the bottle may have been purchased by the murderer in Tacoma is considered significant.
“The label had been scratched off with premeditated purpose of destroying a clue; but the bottle was of a peculiar shape.”
This 1891 case highlights the era's reliance on physical evidence tracking before modern forensics. While the Fetting murder feels like a historical snapshot, the search for a specific retail trail for hazardous goods remains a staple of modern police procedural work.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.