The Desperate Struggle for Winter Heat
Two destitute women caught raking coal from railroad cars were brought before a local justice, who faced a hard choice between the law and the reality of poverty.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
Mrs. Mary Cameron and Mrs. Laura McGlynn, charged with stealing coal from the cars of the Oregon Improvement Company, were found guilty of petit larceny yesterday before Justice Caldwell and were each fined $5 and costs, but in both cases the fines were suspended. It was clearly proven that the women were in the habit of standing by the side of the Oregon Improvement Company's railway tracks, south of the city, and, as the coal cars passed along, rake off chunks of coal with long iron hooks. After the train passed they would gather up the coal and take it home. Mrs. Cameron pleaded not guilty, but the testimony of the company was uncontradicted and her guilt was proven. Mrs. McGlynn, seeing the outcome of Mrs. Cameron's case, was filled with fear and she wept, pleaded guilty and threw herself upon the mercy of the court. Both women have large families to support and are destitute. If the justice had insisted on the payment of their fines they would have been compelled to go to jail for the simple reason that they had no money. For some time past Mrs. McGlynn has received aid from the Bureau of Associated Charities. Not wishing to be too hard on the women the justice suspended sentence and allowed them to return to their families.
“Both women have large families to support and are destitute. If the justice had insisted on the payment of their fines they would have been compelled to go to jail for the simple reason that they had no money.”
This incident highlights the brutal realities of the 1890s depression, where basic survival—such as scavenging coal to heat a home—was criminalized. Today's Seattle struggles with similar tensions regarding survival, where the criminalization of poverty often intersects with public safety debates.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.