The Strange Odyssey of the Boy and the Stolen Buggy
When a 17-year-old was caught stealing a horse and buggy, his strange behavior revealed not a criminal mind, but a tragic descent into mental illness.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
Peter R. Fisher, a boy about 17 years of age, attended a dance at Boren Hall on Saturday night, but left the festivities and, after untying several of the hitched horses nearby, drove off in a rig that did not belong to him. The owner hastened to town and made a complaint before Justice Lawrence. Constable Green hastened away with a warrant for the arrest of the thief, who was then unknown. A farmer named Brown had, however, been on the trail and found the buggy where the road ran out. He followed the horse's tracks for several miles through the woods and through a new clearing and finally came upon it. The thief was not there, but he followed on to where the tracks went out into the road and found he had evidently gotten into a passing vehicle. Four miles further on, he came upon him in the middle of the road. He took him to his own home and put him to bed, seeing that he was a mere boy and not in his right mind. But this morning, Farmer Brown got up and found that his prisoner had flown. Farmer Brown then took down the dinner horn, whistled for his family dog, and went in the direction where he had come, overtaking the boy making for Winlock. He brought the boy to town this morning and went before Probate Judge Wickersham, who adjudged him insane and sent him to Steilacoom. The parents of the unfortunate boy say that he has been acting strangely for about two weeks and has been getting worse during that time.
“He took him to his own home and put him to bed, seeing that he was a mere boy and, more than that, that he was not in his right mind.”
This 1888 account highlights the recurring tension in criminal justice: the historical failure to distinguish between criminal behavior and mental health crises. Just as in modern Seattle, where debates over police response to mental health episodes remain urgent, this story reveals a community struggling to navigate the difference between punishment and care.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.