The Brutality Aboard the Challenger
A captain escapes conviction, but his mates are sentenced for systematic cruelty against seamen.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
Captain Mountford, of the ship Challenger, was indicted on two charges by the last Grand Jury: one for cruelty to sailors, and one for manslaughter, on account of his failure to attempt to pick up one of the ship's crew who had fallen or jumped overboard on the trip out. On the first charge the jury failed to agree, and on the second the captain was acquitted. The first mate, Conway, was convicted on two out of five or six indictments, and was sentenced to four years on the first charge—that of throwing Smith up—and eighteen months for striking one of the sailors with a belaying pin. John Bennett, the brutal-looking second mate, was convicted on five indictments for cruelty to seamen and was sentenced to four years and nine months altogether. Mr. J. C. Haines, counsel for the defendants, was given until June 1st to prepare bills of exceptions, and it is the intention of that gentleman to carry the cases to the Supreme Court. Conway and Bennett were taken to the penitentiary yesterday afternoon.
“The sailors of the Challenger are getting their witness fees today (one dollar per day and board), but the expenses take up a good deal, one item being 'watchman on ship Challenger during trial, at $2.50 per day.'”
This case highlights the extreme conditions sailors endured in the 19th-century maritime industry, where 'discipline' often crossed into lethal abuse. Today, the case serves as a dark reminder of the labor-law vacuum that existed on the high seas, far removed from the shore-based protections that would later emerge.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.