Same Streets
← All stories

The Myth of the Lazy Laborer

A Seattle newspaper editorial in 1878 berates unemployed men for refusing to repair flood-damaged dykes, framing poverty as a moral failing despite local economic instability.

There is a large class of men in this city, without the necessary means to supply the ordinary necessities of life, who are continually damning the “heathen Chinee,” and making him responsible for all the ills and hardships which they are suffering. At first glance this plea would seem plausible enough, but upon a closer inspection it will be found that much of the destitution complained of is due to an indisposition to accept offers of work, even at remunerative prices; this class of men rather preferring the street corner or main office of the hotel than honest occupation of any sort. As an instance in point, last evening a gentleman from the Stillaguamish called at one of our hotels and stated that he wanted to secure the services of a number of men to assist in repairing the damage done to the dykes in that section by the recent high tides. Although, when the proposal was made, quite a number of persons were present who have been boarding at the hotel on time for several months, complaining of the scarcity of labor, yet strange to say not one of them accepted the situation. Our sympathies are with the distressed of every condition, but from this circumstance we are convinced that in the majority of such cases it has been misdirected. These fellows who make such a loud cry about the hard times and nothing to do, are like the discharged soldier who, when asked to work, said he would sooner sell his shirt than stoop to such degradation.

“These fellows who make such a loud cry about the hard times and nothing to do, are like the discharged soldier who, when asked to work, said he would sooner sell his shirt than stoop to such degradation.”

— Printed in Puget Sound Dispatch (Seattle, Wash. Terr.) 1871-1880, 1878
Then · 1878148 years apartNow · 2026

This 1878 editorial reflects an enduring Seattle tension: the clash between those blaming migrant labor for economic instability and those questioning the availability or desirability of the work being offered. Today, as Seattle grapples with housing insecurity and labor shortages in essential fields, the narrative that the unhoused or underemployed 'prefer' idleness remains a common, if historically unexamined, political trope.

The original page

Puget Sound Dispatch (Seattle, Wash. Terr.) 1871-1880, 1878-02-02. Library of Congress, Chronicling America.

From readers

No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.

About this story

From
Puget Sound Dispatch (Seattle, Wash. Terr.) 1871-1880, FEB 2, 1878, Page 7
Text
Cleaned up from the page — spelling and layout repaired — not a word-for-word transcription. The page itself is above, for exact wording.
Rights
Public domain
Place
47.60323, -122.33028 · placed automatically
The paper in the Library of Congress catalog ↗