The Water Monopoly Fight
A local property owner challenges Aberdeen's city council over water rights, accusing officials of steering the public toward an expensive, pre-owned system for their own profit.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
Editor Herald: The unfair remarks of the editor of the Bulletin leads me to think I should seek representation elsewhere. I have been generous with this city, offering them my water privilege at half its real value and giving them 20 acres of my land for a park to secure the purity of the water. As a reward, the council has allowed their contract with me to expire and put me to trouble and expense. The council enters my property without authority and refuses to open B street, effectively shutting me out of the market. I boil with indignation when I think that because our mayor and councilmen are stockholders in the old water company, they refuse the people the right to vote for a new system unless they purchase the old. The people are being forced to choose 'the old system or no water.' I warn that if I submit at the next election, it is only because I must. I ask only that the people be allowed to vote on the propositions independently. I will not sacrifice my self-respect to win the good will of those in power.
“I boil with indignation when I think that because our mayor and a few of the councilmen are stockholders in the old company, they refuse the people the right to vote a new system, unless they will purchase the old.”
This 1891 letter captures a classic 'municipal capture' grievance, where local officials use their regulatory power to protect private investments. Today’s Aberdeen continues to navigate the complexities of public vs. private utility control and the influence of local developer interests on city planning.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.