The Gambler Who Won by Losing His Mind
A Seattle street scene from 1876 reveals a bizarre twist on luck: a man wins $50 not by knowing the score, but by believing he did.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
HE BEAT THE GAME.
A queer incident occurred last evening in front of an old bank building on Second Street. A large crowd had gathered around a dealer who was running a game. One of the players had proposed a rough-looking stranger to bet $50 that he could not win the game. The stranger accepted, and after some time, declared he had won.
"Won what?" asked the dealer.
"Why, I've won it," replied the stranger, pointing to a statement similar to theirs upon which the bank posted the money, thinking he had found a lunatic.
After a rash retort had been made, the person started by a most terrific cry, took in wonder and alarm at the utterances of the stranger, who, jumping at the group, cried out at every jump:
"I've won! I've won it!"
"Won what?" asked the dealer.
"Why, I've won $50! I bet, in my mind, on the cashier, and he won. Hand over the money."
As the maker had permitted him to play when he lost in his mind, he had to pay out the money. The stranger received the money and also a request to be more sensible in his bets.
In an era before digital banking or even widespread checkbooks, cash was king and physical banks were the center of civic life. This story captures the raw, unregulated nature of early Seattle's gambling culture, where 'mental' bets and public spectacles were common entertainment on Second Street (now 2nd Avenue). It highlights a time when financial transactions were often informal, immediate, and occasionally absurd.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.