The Day the Umpire Declared War: A Baseball Riot in the Tri-Cities
In April 1914, a dispute over a base-running call in Richland escalated into a physical standoff, forcing an umpire to forfeit the game and leaving the Highland team walking off the field in protest.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
In spite of Sunday’s wind and dust the second games of the valley baseball league schedule were played and the results leave Kennewick heading the list with a clean slate, Richland and the Highlands tied for second place and Finley occupying the cellar position.
The game between Richland and the Highlands was not played exactly to schedule as it came to a sudden termination in the sixth inning with the score seven to seven. In this inning war was declared between Captain Gascoigne of the Highlanders and Umpire Lilly. After a wordy battle the Highland team withdrew from the field and the umpire declared a 9 to 0 victory for Richland. The dispute arose over a Richland runner’s cutting third base and the umpire’s failure to see it.
At Finley the Kennewick team won by a score of 11 to 3. Most of Kennewick’s playing was done by Larkin’s right arm which struck out sixteen men and allowed only one hit.
This 1914 dispute over a 'cutting third base' call mirrors modern debates about instant replay and officiating integrity in sports. While today we have video review to settle such arguments, early 20th-century baseball relied on the authority of the umpire—a power that, when challenged by players like Captain Gascoigne, could lead to immediate forfeits and public spectacles.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.