A Critique of Preachers' Neglect of Practical Reform
A biting editorial calls out local clergy for focusing on the 'unknown future' while ignoring the immediate sanitary crises, poverty, and vice plaguing the streets of Seattle.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
What are the signs which indicate in our preachers the 'twice told tale' in the homily? It is when the power of energy is seen to be dissipated; when it is found an effort to get through what was once a cheerful task; when what was once found comparatively easy is beginning to be a trial. Now what a pity so much talent and energy should be thrown away, tilting against the old, crumbling walls of ancient theology, when the environment of Puget Sound's metropolis calls so loudly for the suppression of grievances of practical moment to her present and future well-being. For instance, her wretched sanitary condition—how to improve that, so that the town be protected from small-pox, now raging in San Francisco and the principal cities of California. Or the recent visitation of diphtheria. Or how to build up Seattle's wharves without the 'jobbery' that is on foot, at least on the part of the stake-holders in the ring. Or how to reduce the number of Seattle's whiskey saloons, those crumbling houses and dens of infamy. These are subjects that attract the notice of every stranger that stays over night in the city, as well as every good citizen of the place. But these reverend gentlemen have got their mental proboscis tilted in fair heavenward, and are looking so far into the future state, that they don't seem to see evils at their own doors. If this clerical talent could be diverted, just a little, from the unknown and much debated future, and be induced to grapple with the practical ills of today, this very time, generation and hour, they would be rendering some practical service to their fellow men.
“These reverend gentlemen have got their mental proboscis tilted in fair heavenward, and are looking so far into the future state, that they don't seem to see evils at their own doors.”
This 19th-century critique of 'ivory tower' leadership mirrors today's debates about civic leaders who focus on high-level political posturing while ignoring basic urban infrastructure and public health challenges like housing and sanitation.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.