The School Board's Investigation of Teacher Martina Johnston
A teacher at Denny School faced charges of 'gross vulgarity' brought by the American Protective Association, but her colleagues and former students overwhelmingly defended her character.
The city board of education met to investigate charges of 'gross vulgarity in the school room' brought against Miss Martina Johnston, a teacher at Denny School, by William Carnes on behalf of the American Protective Association. Carnes attempted to introduce hearsay affidavits from children, which were blocked by the board's attorney, who insisted on live testimony. The accusers, two schoolgirls, alleged the use of slang and harsh language, though one admitted the teacher had treated her kindly for months. Conversely, a long list of prominent citizens—including George Donworth and former university presidents—provided stellar character references. Superintendent Barnard explicitly defended Miss Johnston, stating he trusted her with the most unruly children and had never heard her use improper language.
“I consider Miss Johnston a first-class teacher. In fact I have so much confidence in her that in a class of unruly children I selected Miss Johnston as specially qualified to maintain order and discipline.”
This incident reflects the moral panics that often targeted women in public service during the 1890s. The struggle between the political agendas of organizations like the A.P.A. and the professional integrity of educators remains a familiar theme in modern school board disputes.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.