The Mealy Bug Standoff at the Seattle Docks
A county inspector orders 800 boxes of Japanese oranges stripped and fumigated. A horticultural commissioner softens the ruling—and the Japanese consul watches closely.
On Friday of last week, County Inspector W. H. Brown examined 800 boxes of oranges landed from Japan—290 boxes consigned to the J. W. Godwin Commission Co. and the balance to a Japanese trading company—and found them badly infected with the mealy bug and five species of scale. He concluded that it would be necessary to remove the oranges from their paper wrappings, pick out and dump the infected fruit, and fumigate the rest as a precaution. The order would incur considerable expense and trouble. The Japanese informed their consul in Tacoma of the facts and objected to the ruling. Horticultural Commissioner Baker of Tacoma was also informed, and a meeting was arranged where the fruit was examined. Baker agreed the fruit was infested but modified the ruling so the fruit could be placed on the market after being fumigated in the boxes with the wrappers on. Mr. Brown held out vigorously for a more thorough fumigation, claiming the pests would not be killed unless the fruit was taken out of the wrappers. "Mr. Baker's decision is against me," said Mr. Brown, "and it now remains for the scientists of the Department of Agriculture to give their decision."
“Mr. Baker's decision is against me... and it now remains for the scientists of the Department of Agriculture to give their decision.”
Invasive-species inspections at Washington ports are routine now, but this early dispute shows how quickly a pest finding becomes a trade and diplomatic negotiation. The same balancing act—protecting local orchards while keeping imported fruit moving—still shapes the state’s agricultural economy.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.