Same Streets
← All stories

The $35 Fee That Became $335: Insurance Commissioner Schively's Sliding Scale

Olympia investigators say J. H. Schively charged newly organized insurance companies whatever they would bear—then kept the difference. With 75 companies heard from and $8,000 in excess fees alleged, the evidence is headed to the governor.

Olympia, Wash., June 8. — According to George Lee, assistant attorney general, who has been working with the investigating committee, what J. H. Schively, state insurance commissioner, referred to as his "sliding scale" of fees charged newly organized companies, will be the principal fact against him in the impeachment proceedings at the special session of the legislature.

The system alleged to be in vogue in the state insurance commissioner's office was to charge insurance companies as much as they would stand for. A fee of $35 is required by the state from companies seeking admission to do business, but it is alleged that Schively charged anywhere from $35 to $335, the latter rate having been wrung from a company at least once. Of this he would turn over to the state only the legal fee, the rest being diverted to his own purse.

It is stated the committee has heard from 75 out of about 300 insurance companies with whom Schively conducted business, and from these they found that he had collected $8,000 in extortionate fees. Some would not pay all he asked, and from these he took what he could get. Correspondence, cancelled checks and other evidence will be turned over to Gov. Hay by the investigating committee as proof of Schively's extortion.

“The system alleged to be in vogue in the state insurance commissioner's office was to charge insurance companies as much as they would stand for.”

— Printed in The Newport Miner (Newport, WA) 1899-Current, 1909
Then · 1909117 years apartNow · 2026

The alleged scheme was almost painfully simple: the state required $35, but Schively supposedly charged up to $335 and pocketed the rest. Modern debates about transparent fee schedules and independent oversight are the same fight in different clothes—public offices are only as clean as the accounting that watches them.

The original page

The Newport Miner (Newport, WA) 1899-Current, 1909-06-10. Library of Congress, Chronicling America.

From readers

No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.

About this story

From
The Newport Miner (Newport, WA) 1899-Current, JUN 10, 1909, Page 2
Text
Cleaned up from the page — spelling and layout repaired — not a word-for-word transcription. The page itself is above, for exact wording.
Rights
Public domain
Place
47.03553, -122.90083 · placed automatically
The paper in the Library of Congress catalog ↗