Same Streets
← All stories

The Milk That Killed Children: A Call for State Inspection

E. A. McDonald tells the dairymen that impure city milk is a leading killer of children and that Seattle alone employs a milk inspector — and Prof. Pearson adds a wry tale of a cow that supposedly supplied one customer for seventeen years.

E. A. McDonald delivered a short address on 'Control of Milk Supplies in Cities.' He reviewed the various phases of the topic and stated that he believed that the control of the milk supply should be in the hands of the state. A very large part of the deaths of children were due to impurities in milk. Contagious diseases were spread by the same source. At present Seattle is the only one of the cities having a city milk inspector. Not only should proper legislation be framed to improve the conditions but a systematic effort put forth to educate the consumers in the cities on how to handle it and keep it fresh after it reaches their hands. There was a great amount of ignorance in this respect.

Prof. Pearson followed Mr. McDonald, and said that the subject was one that he had been interested in for a long time. Before he became attached to the dairy division he was in the milk business in an Eastern city, and one day, in securing new business, called on an old lady, who said that she did not want to change from her present dealer, because he had furnished her milk from the same cow for 17 years. You are likely to find everything in city milk. It has been found very profitable by certain milkmen in the East to make it a specialty to take extreme pains that the milk they sell is of the very best. It is the policy of the city authorities, including the milk inspectors, health officers, etc., to indorse these enterprising men, and as a consequence people patronize them in preference to dealers who do not take such pains. Some of them have built up large fortunes by this means. A man down in New Jersey who had a very ordinary milk supply fixed up his barn and made it attractive, and invited leading physicians to inspect his dairy. He got indorsements from them regarding the superiority of his milk, and in four or five years he has increased his herd from 12 cows to 500, and sells a good part of his milk for 12 cents per quart and the balance for 8 cents.

“A very large part of the deaths of children were due to impurities in milk. Contagious diseases were spread by the same source.”

— Printed in Ranche and Range (North Yakima, Wash.) 1897-1902, 1899
Then · 1899127 years apartNow · 2026

Before pasteurization and routine inspection, milk-borne disease was a genuine child-killer in American cities, and the dairymen's call for state control anticipated the public-health regime that followed. The old lady's 'same cow for 17 years' is a joke that still lands — and a reminder of how little consumers once knew about what was in the pail.

The original page

Ranche and Range (North Yakima, Wash.) 1897-1902, 1899-01-05. Library of Congress, Chronicling America.

From readers

No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.

About this story

From
Ranche and Range (North Yakima, Wash.) 1897-1902, JAN 5, 1899, Page 10
Text
Cleaned up from the page — spelling and layout repaired — not a word-for-word transcription. The page itself is above, for exact wording.
Rights
Public domain
Place
46.60156, -120.51084 · placed automatically
The paper in the Library of Congress catalog ↗