Death in the Ring at the People's Theater
A sparring match at a downtown variety hall turns fatal, sparking a city-wide crackdown on brutal 'glove contests'.
George Shafer, a young man of 21, engaged in a glove fight with Billy Doyle at the People's Theater, a variety dive at the corner of Third and Washington streets, early yesterday morning. In the seventh round, Shafer sank to the floor unconscious, never regained consciousness, and died at 9:20 a.m. Following the death, police made wholesale arrests at the theater, though they failed to capture Doyle, who is believed to have fled to Tacoma. Since the breakdown of the Seattle Athletic Club, theater managers have increasingly used these 'sparring exhibitions' as a drawing card, attracting both the rougher classes and businessmen seeking entertainment. Despite medical testimony during the inquest that Shafer died from natural causes related to a burst blood vessel and his own state of health, the proprietor J.W. Considine and others face charges for hosting a prize fight.
“Some younger members of the regularly organized club—business men, clerks, others who are in the circle of respectability... have attended these Friday night affairs, and in order to gain a good view of the stage have jostled against the very lowest classes.”
This 1891 incident reflects the late 19th-century struggle between Seattle's 'variety halls'—often centers of vice and unregulated combat—and an increasingly conservative civic push to police public morality. The use of the legal system to clamp down on these venues mirrors later efforts to define and restrict 'nuisance' businesses in the city's downtown core.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.