The Panic-Proof Man
A boisterous braggart in a Grand River grocery store claims he can stop any theater panic with a single revolver—until a fake fire prank proves his cowardice.
Six or eight congenial spirits sat around a stove in a Grand River grocery the other night, and after several other subjects had been exhausted, some one introduced that of panics in churches, theaters, and halls. This gave Mr. Hopewell a chance to remark: 'Gentlemen, I just long to be there.' 'Where?' 'Why, in one of those panics. Yes, sir, I'd give a new twenty-dollar bill to be in the theater one night when there was an occasion for panic.' 'Why?' 'Why, because one cool, level-headed man could stop the thing as easily as you could end up that barrel of flour.' 'Well, I dunno about that,' observed one of the sitters. 'There is something awful in the cry of fire, and hear it where and when you may, it startles and frightens. What would you do in a theater in case there was a cry of fire and a rush?' 'I'd stand upon my seat, pull a revolver from my pocket, and shout out that I'd shoot the first man who attempted to crowd or rush. One cool man would check the panic in ten seconds.' While the subject was being continued, the grocer went to the rear end of the store, poured a little powder on a board, and gave three or four men the wink. Directly there was a bright flash, yells of 'fire!' and 'powder!' and every man sprang up and rushed. Hopewell didn't spring up and talk of shooting. On the contrary, he fell over a lot of baskets piled between him and the door, got up to plow his way over a pile of brooms, and when he reached the sidewalk he was on all-fours, white as a ghost, and so frightened that he never looked back until he reached the opposite side of the street.
“I'd stand upon my seat, pull a revolver from my pocket, and shout out that I'd shoot the first man who attempted to crowd or rush. One cool man would check the panic in ten seconds.”
This 1882 cautionary tale highlights a timeless human flaw: the ease with which we mistake bravado for bravery. It serves as a reminder that public crises often expose the gap between our performative confidence and our actual ability to act when the 'fire' actually starts.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.