Betrayal and Bloodshed on Whidbey Island
A ranching partnership ends in a fatal, cold-blooded ambush near Useless Bay.
The story, cleaned up
A cleaned-up reading of the newspaper page: spelling and layout repaired, one story lifted off a crowded page. It follows the original closely but it is not a transcription. The original page is below; read it if a detail matters.
A correspondent at Port Townsend furnishes us with the following particulars of the recent cold-blooded murder on Whidbey Island. The name of the murdered man was Milton Herron, aged between 40 and 45 years. He was from one of the Western states and had been on this coast about 21 years. The person accused of the murder and now in prison for the crime is named Daniel Dale. He took up a land claim on Whidbey Island, near Useless Bay, about nine years ago. The body of the murdered man was found on Saturday, February 4th, by Messrs. Antle, Thomas Johns, John Bryant, and James Wilson, who went in search of him, as he had not been seen alive since Wednesday morning, January 31st. When this party found him, he was dead and appeared to have been shot in the back of his head. From where Herron had been at work chopping a tree, he evidently started to run to his house after being shot but had gotten only 40 or 50 feet when he dropped dead. About one year ago, Herron went into partnership with Dale in the ranch, putting in about $950 in money. Two or three weeks ago, Herron went to Port Ludlow and purchased goods, charging the balance to Dale and himself as partners. When Dale learned of this, he was very indignant, telling Herron he had no interest in the property. Herron went to Port Townsend for legal advice, and returned on the 30th of January. Dale remained on the ranch, telling neighbors Herron would not return. When questioned by the Sheriff, Dale asked, 'What, have you found Herron?' The prisoner is lodged in jail at Port Townsend to await the action of the Court.
“When Dale learned of this transaction, he was very indignant, applying abusive epithets to Herron and telling him he had no interest in the property.”
Conflicts over land rights, financial partnerships, and resource ownership remain a volatile flashpoint in the Pacific Northwest. This 1872 murder highlights the isolation and high stakes of homesteading life on Whidbey Island, mirroring the tensions over property and legal control that still define rural Washington.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.