The Siege of the Water Works
A property dispute between a private landowner and the city of Aberdeen escalates into a standoff involving armed men, city officials, and an eventual arrest.
Two weeks ago I put my men to work cutting down the bluff at my property. My reasons were two-fold: to prevent the city from putting in water mains in such a way as to ruin the grading of the street, and to make a wagon road to the park. Last Tuesday, while I was at the election, the city sent men to dig a ditch through my property. When I returned, I found them in the ditch. I requested them to stop, which they did, but they returned later. This trick of taking possession of private property without so much as 'by your leave' had been tried as often as I cared to endure it. I decided to call out my workmen to continue the grading. We were drilling holes for blasting when the marshal and several councilmen arrived. Marshal Graham ordered us to quit, claiming he had the authority of the city of Aberdeen in his vest pocket and more in his hip pocket. My men, intimidated, quit. Later that day, I was arrested by Policeman Pearson on a warrant charging me with entering the city's 'close' and stopping their workmen with threats and firearms. I was held over in $500 bail. My reputation is suffering severe damage through the widespread publicity given to this outrage, which is grossly misstated by the public press.
“I have the authority of the city of Aberdeen in my vest pocket and more authority in my hip pocket.”
This 1891 standoff over eminent domain and private property rights reflects the ongoing tension in Aberdeen between civic infrastructure expansion and individual land ownership—a friction still felt today as the city navigates growth and land use.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.