Rumors of Lynching at Monte Cristo Debunked
Business leaders and officials scramble to squash sensational reports of violence against Italian laborers as the Everett & Monte Cristo railroad construction continues.
Rumors that four Italians had been lynched at Smith Bros.' camp on the Monte Cristo road have been proven groundless. Yesterday, Emanuel Tarratti, a former Italian foreman for the camp, arrived in town and confirmed that the reported murder victim, John Nelson, was alive and well. J. O. McFee, paymaster for the road contractors, stated there were no disturbances at any of the camps. George S. Brown, president of the railroad, called the reports 'a story out of whole cloth.' Peter Chiodo, a well-known Italian in the community, criticized the press for their disparaging coverage, noting: 'The Italians are hard-working, saving, industrious people, and should not be classed with Chinamen. It is brutal to speak of them in this manner.'
“The Italians are hard-working, saving, industrious people, and should not be classed with Chinamen. It is brutal to speak of them in this manner.”
This incident exposes the deep-seated xenophobia and anti-immigrant sentiment of the 1890s, where 'yellow journalism' frequently fabricated stories to incite fear. It serves as a reminder of the historical role of media in framing immigrant populations, especially as the Italian community pushed for recognition of their humanity.
From readers
No comments yet. If you know something about this story — a correction, a family memory, a source — it belongs here.